
Our Codebase Looks Risky Ahead of an Acquisition: Who Can Assess It Independently?
Aging systems, AI-assisted code or outdated diligence can raise questions before a sale. Learn who can assess your codebase independently and how to act on the findings.
Nov 16, 2026
Preparing a company for sale brings technology questions into conversations that previously centered on revenue, margins and growth. A legacy application may raise concerns about future maintenance, a buyer may question whether AI-generated code has been properly reviewed and tested, or a private equity-backed company may discover that its original technical due diligence no longer reflects the systems running today. What will a buyer find, and which concerns can the seller address before negotiations begin?
An independent technical assessment examines the codebase, architecture and engineering practices to identify material risks before buyer due diligence begins. It should be conducted by external specialists who did not build the software and whose compensation is independent of the transaction outcome. The findings allow leadership to prioritize immediate fixes, prepare evidence and remediation plans for known issues, and identify larger improvements that may be better addressed after the acquisition.
Why buyers may question a company's technology before an acquisition
Three situations deserve particular attention, especially when a business has grown through acquisitions or substantially changed its software.
1. Systems that have aged in place
Established mid-market businesses may still rely on software developed many years ago to manage billing, customer records or daily operations. These systems can remain reliable and support essential business functions, giving leadership little reason to consider replacing them, particularly when modernization would involve significant cost or operational disruption.
A buyer will want to know whether those systems can be maintained and expanded without excessive cost. Are their components still supported? Does the engineering team understand the critical business logic well enough to maintain and modify it, or is that knowledge concentrated in one person? Documentation may no longer reflect the production environment, and an essential integration could rely on an API that receives limited maintenance.
The software's age tells a buyer little on its own. An independent reviewer can distinguish a stable older system from one with significant security, maintenance or scalability risks, then estimate what addressing those limitations would involve.
2. Code written with AI assistants
AI coding tools can generate code, prepare tests, refactor applications and help engineers complete development tasks more efficiently. In structured AI-assisted development, engineers remain responsible for architecture, code review, testing and deployment, using AI-generated code within established engineering processes. Vibe coding takes a different approach: developers rely primarily on prompts to build software, often with limited inspection or understanding of the resulting code.
Vibe coding can be useful for prototyping and internal experiments, but the risks become more significant when an application built this way begins handling customer information or supporting daily operations. Our article Vibe Coding at Work: From Fast Prototype to Reliable Software examines that transition. An August 2025 article in MIT Sloan Management Review also explores how rapidly introducing AI-generated code into existing systems can contribute to technical debt, particularly when developers lack the experience to recognize architectural problems.
For a seller, the assessment should establish how AI-assisted code reaches production and whether the team maintains adequate oversight. Four areas deserve particular attention:
- Code review and ownership. Can engineers explain important implementation decisions, and is AI-generated code reviewed by qualified team members before being incorporated into the application.
- Testing and deployment. Do automated tests verify that essential functions, such as processing transactions or updating customer records, work correctly? Can the team quickly identify and reverse software changes that introduce errors in production?
- Architecture. Have AI-generated components introduced dependencies or decisions that make the application harder to modify or maintain?
- Data handling. What information reaches external AI tools, and which controls govern that access?
The presence of AI-generated code should not automatically count against a company. When teams use these tools responsibly, AI-assisted development can become a competitive advantage, helping accelerate delivery, strengthen testing and make better use of engineering capacity. Documented reviews, effective quality controls and clear technical ownership help demonstrate that the company can benefit from these tools while maintaining software quality. Evidence of faster delivery or improved productivity can strengthen that case further.
3. Technical due diligence that no longer reflects the business
A private equity-backed company may have a technical due diligence report from its original acquisition, but that assessment reflects the technology at a particular moment. Infrastructure migrations, add-on acquisitions, new integrations or changes in engineering practices can substantially alter the environment during the holding period.
An updated review allows the seller to revisit earlier findings, identify new dependencies and document improvements achieved since the investment. For a private equity firm preparing an exit, that record can help demonstrate how technology investments supported scalability, operational efficiency or integration of acquired businesses.
Who can assess a codebase independently?
An independent technical assessment should be performed by qualified external reviewers who were not responsible for developing or maintaining the software under review.
Sellers have several options: specialized technical due diligence firms, software engineering consultancies with assessment experience, and independent CTO-level advisors. Some M&A advisory firms also have technology teams capable of conducting these reviews.
The most appropriate choice depends on the complexity of the technology environment and the expertise required. An assessment focused on security may require application security specialists, while evaluating legacy systems, complex integrations and potential modernization costs calls for hands-on engineering experience. In either case, the report should provide sufficient technical and financial detail to support discussions with prospective buyers.
A credible assessment requires three conditions:
- Independence from the original development team. Reviewers should have no responsibility for the software or technical decisions they are evaluating.
- Independent commercial terms. Fees and deliverables should not depend on the findings, transaction outcome or subsequent remediation work.
- Evidence-based conclusions. Findings should be supported by code, infrastructure records, tests and operational evidence, with interviews providing context.
The internal engineering team supplies documentation, access and explanations of technical decisions, while independent reviewers evaluate the evidence. A current technology provider faces a conflict when assessing its own work. A firm that performed an earlier assessment may be considered if it remains independent of the development under review.
The report should distinguish risks with material business implications from lower-impact issues. A security vulnerability affecting a customer-facing application, for example, deserves different attention from an aging internal tool with limited exposure. For a more detailed look at assessment methodology, we recommend reading our article, The Complete Guide to Technical Due Diligence for Acquisitions.
Can the same firm assess and remediate the findings?
A firm conducting a technical assessment may also offer modernization, architecture or security services. That experience can help estimate remediation, provided the assessment is a standalone engagement with defined deliverables and compensation independent of future implementation work.
Any remediation should be contracted separately, and the seller must remain free to choose another provider. At Making Sense, our technical due diligence work connects engineering findings with their business implications, including operational risks, critical integrations and technology constraints that could affect growth.
How assessment findings influence valuation and acquisition planning
A technical assessment can uncover many findings, but they differ in severity, cost and relevance to the transaction. Leadership needs to decide which issues to address before the sale and which to document for buyer discussions. Three paths are common:
1. Resolve issues before the sale process
Some findings can be addressed before the sale without major changes to the underlying systems. Examples include exposed credentials that need to be replaced or backup procedures that have never been tested to confirm the company can recover its data and applications after a failure. Resolving these issues early can reduce operational risks and prevent avoidable questions during buyer due diligence.
2. Document limitations and prepare a remediation plan
Consider a critical application built on an outdated framework. Upgrading it may require changes to integrations, extensive regression testing and coordination with teams that depend on it daily. Completing the work before a sale could introduce more disruption than the business can reasonably accept.
The seller still needs a clear understanding of the technical dependencies, estimated remediation costs and risks associated with postponing the work. A documented plan helps management explain the issue and its potential financial implications to prospective buyers. Legal and M&A advisors can then determine how and when to disclose these findings during due diligence and address any concerns that arise during acquisition negotiations.
3. Identify improvements better addressed after acquisition
Some technology investments depend on what the buyer plans to do with the business after the acquisition. For example, a seller may be considering a major redesign of its customer management system, while a prospective buyer intends to integrate that application with software already used across its other businesses. Completing the redesign before understanding those plans could result in unnecessary costs or work that needs to be repeated after closing.
An assessment can estimate the constraints and effort involved without prescribing an expensive pre-sale overhaul. Priorities should reflect the severity of the risk, the cost of remediation and its relevance to prospective buyers. A security issue in a revenue-generating system will generally deserve more attention than a modernization opportunity with limited exposure.
The connection to merger IT integration
Buyers use technical findings to inform merger IT integration plans, including which systems to retain, consolidate or replace. Integration work can expose dependencies overlooked in an architecture overview: customer data moving between several applications, financial reports relying on scheduled jobs, or manual reconciliations maintained by a small team. Finding those dependencies late may require revising migration estimates and integration timelines.
An accurate architecture map, integration inventory and record of known limitations make those conversations more productive. For private equity firms preparing an exit, an updated assessment can also document improvements in scalability, reliability and integration capacity achieved during the holding period. Those results fit into the broader relationship between technology due diligence and value creation from acquisition through exit.
Seeing the platform the way a buyer will
A seller has more options when technology risks are understood before buyer diligence begins. Some findings call for prompt fixes; others warrant a costed remediation plan or decisions made with the future owner's strategy in mind. A current assessment also gives management a record of improvements already achieved, from modernization to stronger engineering practices.
At Making Sense, we conduct technical due diligence assessments for mid-market businesses and private equity firms, helping leadership understand technology risks, evaluate remediation priorities and prepare for acquisition discussions. If your company is approaching a sale, let's discuss how an independent technical assessment can help you identify and address potential concerns before buyers begin their review.
Frequently asked questions
When should a company commission an independent technical assessment before a sale?
Several months before opening the data room is preferable when possible. The assessment may take a few weeks, depending on complexity, and subsequent documentation or remediation can take longer.
What role should the internal engineering team play?
Engineers provide system access, documentation and context for technical decisions, then help address findings. External reviewers conduct the independent evaluation.
Does AI-generated code require a different assessment?
Security, reliability, maintainability and scalability remain central. Reviewers should also examine oversight of generated code, testing practices and controls on data shared with external AI tools.
Is a technical due diligence report from a previous acquisition still useful?
Yes. It offers a historical baseline, but material changes to systems, integrations, teams or engineering practices may justify a fresh review before the next transaction.
Nov 16, 2026